Llamas vs Alpacas: 5 Key Ways To Tell the Difference

When I first got into homesteading, I was researching all the different types of livestock. The most confusing part for me was trying to tell the difference between llamas and alpacas. While it may be easy for some, I just could not see the difference. So, I did some digging to find the key distinctions between llamas and alpacas. Here’s what I found.

The main differences between llamas and alpacas are their size, ears, and fleece. Llamas are nearly twice the size, have banana-shaped ears, and grow a fleece that’s more coarse than alpacas. Additionally, alpacas are generally friendlier than llamas and spit less often. However, llamas make better livestock guardians.

CharacteristicsLlamasAlpacas
Average Height44″35″
Average Weight300-400lbs100-200lbs
EarsBanana-shapedSmaller and pointed
FleeceCoarseSoft
Maximum number per acre84
Do they spit?YesYes
LifespanUp to 30 yearsUp to 25 years
FriendlinessLess friendlyMore friendly

But while these are the key differences when it comes to llamas vs alpacas, some specifics might help you out. Continue reading to see some resources that I’ve made to help show more about how llamas and alpacas are different.

1. Llamas Are Twice the Size

llama vs alpaca
The most notable differences between alpacas and llamas

One of the biggest differences between llamas and alpacas is their size. Llamas generally reach a height of around 44″, or slightly under 4′ tall, while alpacas can grow to a height of about 35″, or right under 3′ tall.

While this doesn’t seem like much, the end result is that alpacas are about half the size, coming in at between 100-200 lbs, while llamas weigh 300-400 lbs. This can make quite a bit of a difference when you’re keeping them as livestock on your homestead.

For example, with their lighter weight and soft toes, alpacas don’t tread as hard, so they don’t crush and kill grass as other hooved-livestock can.

Additionally, with their extra size, llamas require more food and land to range.

For more information about what to feed llamas and alpacas, check out my other post: the complete guide to feeding llamas and alpacas.

It’s recommended to keep up to 4 llamas per acre, and up to 8 alpacas per acre.

So, if you’re looking to keep the most livestock per acre, then alpacas’ compactness wins this round.

2. Llamas Have Banana-Shaped Ears

llama vs alpaca ears
Llamas (left) have longer, slightly curved ears that many refer to as “banana” shaped

The next main difference between llamas and alpacas is the size and shape of their ears. Llamas have larger, banana-shaped ears, while alpacas have smaller and pointed ears.

This is one of the easiest ways to tell llamas and alpacas apart, especially in photos where you can’t compare their size.

3. Llamas Spit Slightly More Often

One of the most common questions for llamas and alpacas are if they spit. Here’s the answer.

Generally, both llamas and alpacas spit, but only when they’re feeling threatened or if they’re really bothered. Most times, llamas and alpacas rarely spit, with alpacas spitting less often. Because their spit is a type of vomit, if you’re spit on, it’s best to remove it before the bacteria spreads.

However, if you’re thinking about raising alpacas, and you’re concerned about them spitting, know that this is something you’ll rarely have to deal with, if ever.

To learn more about why llamas and alpacas spit, and what you can do about it, check out this video by WildCiencias.

4. Alpaca Wool Is Softer

Alpaca wool is extremely well-known and prized for being lightweight, warm, and strong. On the other hand, most llamas have a coarser and shorter fleece, so it’s not as practical to farm or process. While there are some wooly llama breeds, it’s still not as common to use compared with alpaca wool.

alpaca wool in baskets

Even though they have different coats, both llamas and alpacas need to be shorn every spring to avoid overheating in the warmer months. Since llamas and alpacas have been highly domesticated (originally from South America), they can no longer shed their coats on their own and require human intervention to survive.

white alpaca getting shorn

While this may seem sad, llamas and alpacas aren’t found in the wild anymore, so they’ve become dependent on us to shear their fleeces. Without shearing, their coat will keep growing and they would overheat and die.

Compared to cotton, polyester, and acrylic, wool stays cleaner longer, has anti-bacterial properties, and keeps you warmer or cooler, depending on the weather.

Okay, small detour–even though I don’t use alpaca wool, I switched most of my closet to merino wool (from sheep) and can vouch for the difference. My cotton and plastic clothes used to get dirty after one time of wearing them. Now, I can wear a wool t-shirt for a few days without it getting dirty or smelling. It sounds weird, but it’s true, and who doesn’t want to do less laundry? I’d love to try out some alpaca wool clothing soon.

Going back to alpacas, their wool is much softer than llamas, and with each fleece, or “blanket”, selling between $100 to $1,500, alpaca farming can definitely be a profitable venture. The pricing largely varies depending on the quality of fiber and how it’s processed.

Take a look at this table and data from Apple Mountain Alpacas:

Fiber TypePrice Per Pound
Raw Fleece$0-$10
Skirted and Sorted$1-$28
Roving and Batts$50-$75
Yarn$100-$150

So, if you’re trying to see if llamas or alpacas are more profitable to raise, know that alpacas are generally more profitable, considering you can effectively raise them, shear, and process their fibers properly.

5. Alpacas Are Generally Friendlier

Generally, alpacas are more friendly than llamas, however, there are exceptions. Their friendliness comes down to their nurture and their nature. Sometimes you’ll have the odd llama who’s more of a spitter or slightly more aggressive.

In any case, before you introduce a new member to the alpaca or llama herd, make sure to observe their behavior. While rescuing is a noble deed, it can sometimes lead to compatibility problems with the herd. Once you’ve deemed that the new addition should make a good fit with the rest of the herd, slowly introduce them.

A good way to do this is to keep them in a separate paddock, but in one where they can both see each other.

Over a couple weeks, let them occasionally run with each other while keeping an eye on aggression, competitiveness, or other negative behaviors.

If you’re also wondering if llamas and alpacas can be kept together, check out my post about llamas and alpacas living together.

If you’d like to see alpaca’s behavior in action, along with some other tips, check out this video by Happy Tails. Meghan is great with animals and I binge-watched some of her alpaca videos when I was first learning about them.

Final Thoughts

Now, whenever I see a picture of a llama or alpaca, it still takes me a second, but I can usually tell the difference (the ears are what I look at first).

If you’re deciding on whether to keep llamas or alpacas, it usually comes down to the amount of feed and land you can provide, as well as what you’d like them for. While you can keep more alpacas and use their wool, llamas are better livestock guardians and can occasionally protect chickens and other livestock.

Tyler Ziton

After years of fatigue and declining health, Tyler found that good, fresh food was his answer. He learned more about healthy food by completing a certification in health coaching, and from there decided to grow his own food and become more self-sufficient. Tyler also runs a consulting company to help gardeners and website owners solve problems. Read more.

Recent Posts