A friend of mine has a pear tree that’s not doing too well—its leaves are curling and dropping. They asked if I had an idea of what could be happening to it and how to fix it, so I did some research to find out. Here’s what I found out about pear trees dying (and how to save them).
Pear trees typically die from improper watering, nutrients, or climate. However, transplant shock, pests, and disease can also affect them. For best results, water only when the soil is dry, apply compost, and plant in USDA hardiness zones 4-8. Once the source of stress is reduced, the pear tree should recover.
So, while pear trees die for several reasons, can they be saved, and how can they be saved? Let’s take a closer look.
Can Dying Pear Trees Be Saved?
Dying pear trees can be revived if you first find the proper issue and apply a timely solution. The hard part is finding out which issue is affecting them. However, a good approach is to start with the possible issues based on the symptoms and try solutions starting from the least invasive to the most invasive.
The reason why we want to start with the least invasive solution first is to minimize the stress your pear tree gets. For example, if we’ve narrowed down the possible issues to a lack of water or drainage, it’s much easier on the pear tree to adjust its watering than it is to spray it with chemicals or dig it up.
By approaching solutions in this way, it makes it easier for you to treat your pear tree, as you can work your way up from simple solutions to more complex ones.
How Do You Know if Your Pear Tree Is Dying?
It can be difficult to tell if your pear tree is dying or not, but generally, if it has any of the below symptoms, it’s likely declining in health.
|Pear Tree Symptom||Issue*|
|Wilting/Curling Leaves||Under-Watered, Heat Stress, Transplant Shock|
|Yellow Leaves||Under/Over-Watered, Transplant Shock, Lack or Excess Nutrients, Pests|
|Brown Leaves||Under-Watered, Heat/Frost Stress, Transplant Shock, Pests|
|Spotted Leaves or Fruit||Pests or Diseases|
|Dropping Leaves||Under/Over-Watered, Heat/Frost Stress, Transplant Shock, Lack or Excess Nutrients, Pests or Diseases|
|Dropping Fruit||Under/Over-Watered, Heat/Frost Stress, Transplant Shock, Lack or Excess Nutrients, Lack of Pollination, Pests or Diseases|
Keep in mind that these symptoms aren’t normally a cause for concern if they’re affecting less than 10-20% of the plant. For example, it’s fairly normal for 10-20% of your pear tree’s leaves to be yellow or brown. The same is true for some flower or fruit drop.
However, if more than 20% of the tree is affected, or you’re seeing other concerning signs such as pest or disease symptoms, then action is likely needed to save the tree.
Also, pear trees are deciduous trees, so it’s normal for them to lose their leaves in the fall and winter. This is a strategy to reduce the tree’s energy expenditure and go into dormancy to survive the winter (much like bears hibernating).
On the other hand, evergreen fruit trees typically are native to more tropical climates (with little to no frost), such as citrus trees. As a result, evergreen fruit trees keep their leaves year-round.
So don’t stress if your pear tree is losing its leaves in the fall or winter! However, if your pear tree is losing its leaves early (in the spring or summer), or has other symptoms, continue reading to see what we can do to help it.
How To Save a Dying Pear Tree
If you’ve already tried finding out which issue your pear tree has, and you’ve gotten stuck, there’s still hope.
Here are 3 steps you can use to save your pear tree, for just about any condition.
3 Quick Steps To Save a Dying Pear Tree
1. Identify the Possible Issues
The first step in reviving a dying pear tree is to identify the possible issues. After all, the process of elimination wouldn’t work if we didn’t know which options we were eliminating!
If you haven’t seen them yet, reference the below sections for the top 5 most common pear tree issues.
2. Isolate the Actual Issue
Once you’ve checked the specific symptoms your pear tree has, you can now cross off potential issues from your list.
Try to get it down to 1-3 potential issues that best match the symptoms your pear tree is exhibiting. This will give you the best chance to provide the right solution for it (you don’t want to spray the tree with neem oil if the problem is a watering issue).
If you’re still not sure about the issue your pear tree has, that’s okay! Call up your local nursery and get their opinion on what’s happening. You may need to talk to a few people to get their experience, but there’s a strong chance they’ve seen it before and can point you in the right direction (or even provide you with the solution!).
Additionally, you can contact your local professional orchard or cooperative extension service.
3. Test Solutions
Now that you have a narrowed-down list of the potential issues, it’s time to try the solutions one at a time.
Start with the least invasive and work your way up to the most invasive. Again, providing less water is much easier than going through the process of repotting the tree. Try to save that option for last.
Continue testing the treatments you believe are most likely to fix the issue. Hopefully, one of them sticks.
Worst case scenario, start from step 1 and make a new list of possible issues. There’s a chance you might have missed something or you notice something new the second time around.
Stay persistent! It’s easy to say, “Dumb plant, why don’t you want to live?”, but there’s always a reason why plants act the way they do. Keep the course and see if you can uncover it.
Now, to give you a head start on treating your pear tree, let’s look at the 5 most common reasons why pear trees die.
The Top 5 Reasons Why Pear Trees Die
1. Over or Under-Watering
Over and under-watering commonly leads to a dying pear tree, with under-watering being the most frequent cause. Too little water and the pear tree’s leaves curl, brown, and drop. Too much water causes root rot and dropping leaves. Only water when the soil is dry and provide 2 inches of compost and mulch.
When pear trees are under-watered, their leaves curl to conserve moisture. If left for too long, the leaves will begin to dry further and brown. Occasionally, this leads to leaf drop, although some pear trees keep their brown leaves. Under-watering is common in hot and dry climates, where soil moisture can be evaporated in a matter of hours.
On the other hand, over-watered pear trees often cause stagnant water in the soil and root rot. This is especially common for soils with poor drainage. Once water-logging occurs, the pear tree becomes stressed until the roots can have a chance to dry out a bit and fight off the root rot mold. If left with root rot, the roots decay, leading to more brown leaves before killing the tree.
While there is a lot of information out there about how to water plants, the best rule is to only water when the soil is dry. This prevents both over and under-watering as you’re only watering when the plant needs it.
Also, providing 2 inches of each compost and mulch on top of the soil goes a long way to helping the soil hold more water and increase the water independence of the tree. It also encourages deeper roots that can access deeper water. However, this should only be done once the pear tree has well-draining soil as these practices can make poor drainage worse.
Here’s a bit more information about compost and mulch (and why they’re so beneficial for your pear tree).
Compost provides valuable nutrients to the soil and increases the soil’s richness and water retention. For example, every 1% increase in the soil’s richness can hold an additional 20,000 gallons of water per acre (source). It also feeds beneficial soil life such as earthworms and mycorrhizal fungi—which provide even more nutrients and disease resistance for the tree.
Mulch protects the soil (and the beneficial soil life) from drying out in the sun and wind. In hot and dry weather, mulch dramatically reduces evaporation and locks in moisture from the soil. In cold weather, mulch provides a layer of insulation for the tree and its roots. Some good mulches for pear trees are leaves, bark, pine needles, and straw.
So, to recap:
Once you have well-draining soil, only water pear trees when the first 2-4 inches of soil are dry. I check for this by pushing a finger into the soil. Then, apply 2 inches of each compost and mulch under the drip line of the plant, keeping them at least 3 inches from the trunk. Reapply compost every 1-2 months.
If you need to test your soil’s drainage, you can dig a 1-foot by 1-foot hole near the pear tree and fill it with water. If the hole drains slower than 2 inches per hour, it has poor drainage.
Also, make sure to dig the hole outside of the tree’s canopy to avoid damaging the shallow roots.
Since it can be difficult to amend garden soil due to the volume of amendments needed, and if the tree is already planted, providing compost and mulch on top of the soil is generally the best way. This way you avoid digging up the tree (which potentially causes transplant shock). However, it takes time to amend the soil as the compost and mulch break down and work their way into the soil.
For potted pear trees, you can test the soil’s drainage by seeing if the water runs out of the pot’s drainage holes. If the top of the soil is staying wet for days after watering, the tree likely needs to be repotted with fresh soil.
To see which potting soils I recommend for fruit trees, check out my post: The Top 3 Potting Soils for Fruit Trees (Tested).
2. Transplant Shock
If a pear tree was recently planted or repotted, and it’s starting to die, it’s likely due to transplant shock. Transplant shock occurs when the plant is exposed to a new environment and has to establish a new root system. Avoid transplanting unless necessary as it can take up to 1 year for recovery.
Like many plants, pear trees are vulnerable to transplant shock, which can take up to a year for them to recover from. To help avoid transplant shock, I like to plant with the following steps in mind:
- Have the new ground (or pot) prepared
- Remove as much of the tree’s current topsoil as possible, without damaging the shallow roots
- Grab the base of the tree’s trunk and wiggle lightly
- Using your other hand, scoop up and support the rootball
- Lightly place the tree in the new ground (or pot) and fill it in
- Make sure the soil is at the same level on the trunk as before
- Apply 2 inches of compost and 4 inches of mulch to the top of the soil
- Water generously and add more soil as needed
3. Lack of Nutrients
If you’re using chemical fertilizers, provide pear trees with a balanced NPK (nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium), such as a 10-10-10. Alternatively, you can apply 2 inches of compost every 1-2 months. Unlike chemical fertilizers, compost has other benefits such as improved water retention.
Too few or too many nutrients causes yellow and brown leaves on pear trees. With too few nutrients, pear trees can’t support their leaves’ requirements, which then start to discolor and die. Too many nutrients chemically burn the plant’s roots and lead to browning and dropping leaves. Ideally, provide quality fertilizer or compost.
Keep in mind that soil pH is equally, if not more important than nutrients. Without a proper soil pH, the pear tree’s roots will be unable to absorb nutrients in the soil. This also leads to discoloring and dying leaves.
Generally, pear trees prefer a soil pH of 6.0-6.5.
You can measure soil pH with pH strips or a pH meter. I prefer using a pH meter since they’re easy to use and affordable. To see which pH meter I use and recommend, visit my recommended tools page.
4. Climate Stress
Pear trees are natively from temperature climates, so they prefer cooler environments such as USDA hardiness zones 4-8. However, this is a generalization as there are varieties that prefer warmer or colder zones.
Climates that are too cold (below zone 4) or those that are hot and dry quickly pose a problem for pear trees. In dry areas such as California, Arizona, Nevada, and parts of Texas, pear trees lose moisture from their leaves and soil quickly.
Much like humans, plants breathe and release moisture when hot. For plants, this is called transpiration. When the climate is too hot and dry, the transpiration and root moisture can’t effectively keep up and cool the plant and its leaves. When this happens, the pear tree’s leaves curl, brown, and sometimes drop.
So, the hotter and drier the weather, the more energy the tree uses to transpire and survive, and the less energy it has to use to establish its root system and grow. This drain of resources can quickly stunt or kill the tree.
By the way, if you live in a drier climate, and you’d like more information about the best drought-tolerant fruit trees, check out my other post: 30 Best Drought-Tolerant Fruit and Nut Trees (Ranked).
For best results, keep pear trees in a cool and mild climate if possible. If the sun is too hot, and the tips of the leaves are browning, provide shade or move potted pear trees indoors. When bringing potted pear trees indoors, take care to avoid the hot and dry air from the central heat.
I found out about the effects of central heat the hard way. We had a surprise snowstorm last year here in Austin, Texas, and I moved my potted Meyer lemon tree inside. However, it quickly started losing its leaves. After moving it into a cooler room, it quickly started growing new leaves (see the photo below).
I would also suggest not moving potted pear plants indoors during the winter as they typically require 200-800 chill hours (under 45ºF). This dormancy is healthy for pear trees as they reserve energy during the winter to explode in growth during the spring.
However, if temperatures fall below -30ºF (the standard zone 4 minimum temperature), the pear tree will likely start to die. In this case, move the potted tree indoors or into a greenhouse. For planted trees, you can provide 6-12 inches of mulch such as leaves to help insulate the tree. You can also reduce the wind and ice by covering the canopy with a sheet or tarp.
5. Pests and Diseases
Pests and diseases such as aphids, mites, pear scab, and fire blight can cause pear trees to die. Most pests can be repelled with water, oils, or sprays, while diseases can be treated with organic sprays or fungicides. Some pests and diseases such as aphids can be deterred with companion plants like garlic.
While not as common as the other issues on this list, pests and diseases also lead to dying pear trees. Generally, you can tell if your pear tree has a disease by inspecting the leaves for any brown or yellow spots or deformities.
You can also typically tell if pests are infecting the tree if you see them gathering on the underside of the leaves (like aphids) or holes in the tree (like borers).
For more information about pear tree pests, check out this resource by the University of Maryland Cooperative Extension. For pear tree diseases, try this resource by The Connecticut Agriculture Experiment Station.
A Note on Pesticides and Fungicides
My parents recently had an issue with caterpillars eating their basil plants in Ventura, CA, and they were about fed up. Every time they’d plant basil, the caterpillars ate it. Fortunately, instead of giving into chemical sprays, they found an organic spray at their local nursery that’s made from fermented rum. The day after spraying, they’d find dead caterpillars on the soil.
If you’d like to find out more about this organic spray, you can find it here on Amazon.
So, what’s my point here?
Even though chemical sprays and fertilizers are an easy way out, like all easy and convenient things, there are usually long-term costs. Namely to the plants, soil, and surrounding beneficial life. Before using conventional sprays, weigh the pros and cons and consider trying organic or permaculture-based treatments first.
To give you a head start, Stefan Sobkowiak – The Permaculture Orchard has a great video on a safe, homemade, and most importantly—effective fungicide (hint: the secret ingredient is whey).
Is Your Fruit Tree Beyond Saving?
You can generally tell if a fruit tree is still alive by either pruning or lightly scratching off some bark from a small branch. If there’s any green inside, the plant is still alive.
If it’s not alive, revisit what may have happened (was the wrong climate, watering, nutrients, etc?) and adjust as needed for your other affected plants.
If it’s time to replace your fruit tree, or add more to your orchard, the best places to get them are your local nursery, or an online nursery. They’ll have a good selection and offer varieties that grow well in your area.
For example, I get my fruit trees from the online nursery Fast Growing Trees, and all of them have been delivered quick, neat, and healthy.
After repotting, and providing them with plenty of water and compost, they quickly recovered from the minor transplant shock and started growing nicely!